Why Your Resume Won’t Get You Your Dream Job

5215752479 db700717c0 Why Your Resume Wont Get You Your Dream Job

As I was driving home a few days ago, I was thinking about how I ended up with the greatest job in the world. A few weeks back when I spoke at Pepperdine, I started the speech by talking about the inherent limitation of resumes. The more I thought about it, the more I started to realize that there was no way a resume could lead somebody to their dream job.

Go ask somebody who has their dream job and I doubt you’ll hear “I submitted it on indeed.com, monster.com, etc., interviewed with the company, and it was a perfect fit.”  Chances are it came through a referral, connection or some other source. When your resume is the only tool in your job search arsenal you are essentially forcing square pegs into round holes.  If a few of the bullet points on the job description match up with a few of the bullet points on your resume, then you apply. If they don’t match up you try to adjust them so they match up accordingly.  Can you see why this can’t possibly lead to you finding your dream job?

I’m not saying it won’t lead to finding a job. It just won’t lead to your dream job. Dan Schawbel even wrote about the demise of job boards. Every job I’ve had up until my current one was purely a byproduct of my resume. I hated almost every one of those jobs and I wasn’t even good at them.

Human beings by nature are dynamic. Resumes are not. If you’re telling me that you can express who you are in one page, then I think you really need to go out and get a life.  There’s no way you can possibly express how dynamic and interesting you are with bullets on one page. Finding the company that lets you be you is never going to happen with just a resume since this is all it will tell them:

  • Where you went to school
  • Where you’ve worked
  • Some skills/accomplishments
  • Your Contact Information

There’s no way that YOU are defined by just that.  But don’t take my word for it. Look at the titles of these recent articles on the Havard Business Review Blog:

If a publication that is coming from one of the best business schools in the world is saying this, maybe it’s time to listen.

The Power of a Personal Brand

Spend a few minutes reading through The Skool of Life or look at my tweet stream and you’re going to get a much deeper insight into who I am as a person and what my real strengths are than you ever would from my resume:

  • My ideas and philosophy on life and business are expressed here in a way that my core values become quite apparent
  • I can use the power of something like YouTube to showcase public speaking skills
  • Various projects that I’m working on give me an ability to demonstrate my creative capacity
  • I can showcase TANGIBLE evidence of all the things I know how to do

In many ways, this gives me an opportunity to filter out all the organizations that would never be a good fit for me on a personal level. It also gives them an opportunity not to waste time with a candidate who wouldn’t be a good fit. My boss hires software developers and the one thing he tells me is that every single resume and cover letter is exactly the same. As a result it’s incredibly challenging to find the right person.  I think skills developed and showcased from building your online brand can be beneficial to any job regardless of your field.

Given that building your brand could ultimately lead to a more fulfilling personal and professional life, isn’t it worth doing?

The Skool of Delivered to Your Inbox
Sign up for my FREE Course on the 7 Most Important Things You Never Learned in School
Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

This is exactly where I am today – Trying to figure out how to make my CV stand out – to energize it with who I am and my creativity and innovative spirit – Attempting to ascertain what I can write that will intrigue someone??
Jobs are, to a large extent, still about the CV… Given that this is the way of the world today… how does one reach out and grab attention saying… you want to hire me as this is what I bring to the table!

Great post, Srini. I love your directness here. This article perfectly illustrates your point: YOU come through in your writing in a way that you couldn't possibly in a list of your jobs, educational qualifications, or hobbies.

I pick this very topic up in one of my Career Coaching Q&A videos: 'How Important Is A Good Curriculum Vitae': http://youtu.be/oFBuQV8Wcb4

Brian,

That's precisely the problem with resumes. They're far too generic and they don't give a very genuine picture into who you are. In fact I almost want to follow this up with another post about why submitting a resume makes you insincere. hehe. Thanks for the comment. I"ll definitely take a look at your video.

Great post; I especially liked your points about the power of personal branding. A project such as a blog you've created, especially when it contains things like video content, tells so much more about what you're actually like as an individual and what skills you could bring to a job. A company that reads a list of bullet points will have no idea what you're like in person. Also, it's not much help because everyone just spins their resume to represent what they think the companies want to read, not who they really are.

What would you say to the idea that in the future, resumes will still be useful, but rather than being a standalone resource, they'll serve as more of a gateway into your own life and skill set. For example, you'd give your name and your previous employers, but instead of providing a list of 40 bullet points, you include urls to your blog, twitter feed, or whatever you think best captures what you'd bring to the organization. Some people's resumes have lists of their publications; what if you included your best blog posts?

Srini, this came at just the right time. I was revising my resume just the other day. I will be taking these points to heart.

Christina,

Glad to hear it :). I'm looking forward to hearing about the story.

I was recently told that my resume was too long, and that was why I don't have a job. I do mostly freelance design these days, and I had every job listed individually, listing out what I had done for who and when. Well this all came out to a couple pages. Now I have everything boiled down two one page and I don't think it really makes a difference. I can agree more with what you've said. I know that if I could just meet with employers face to face I'd have more luck, because on paper I look boring and either over qualified or under. My resume doesn't speak to the fact that I often work overtime (some times through the night) to make a deadline (often because some one else didn't do there job) and that I often finish my work then help others with theirs. It doesn't say that graduated high school at seventeen and got my bachelors at twenty one, and that I never partied in college because I'm terrified of failing. I don't think you can cover stuff like that in a cover letter.

Kristin,
I think there's very little that a cover letter and resume will do for anybody in the future. When I watch students struggle through a job search it's incredibly frustrating to me because I feel like they are beating their heads against a brick wall. Despite numerous attempts to convince them of the value of building a brand, I seldom see people making any effort to do it.

Hi Srinivas,

I just went on a rant about this to one of my friends who told me that my resume needs to be one page, and that I need to post it online, so that I can get a "regular" job.
While I do intend to continue being a nurse in some capacity, I don't see how anyone can appreciate, from one page of facts, my experience, (not work experience but total life experience), who I really am and just how valuable I can be to others. It's impossible to sum up my life, experience and value to others in one neat little typed page!
I also complained that I don't want to work for any employer who would hire people from this limited information!
This was yesterday, then I read this blog today. Good timing! lol
I love being validated by outside sources such as your blog. I'm going to send this to my friend.
Thank you,
Roseann

Roseann,

I'm glad to hear it. It's also nice to have somebody outside of this whole social mediia/blogging world validate this notion that a resume is just way too limiting a view into who we are. I think as employers embrace looking for a different way of connecting with people they will actually end up with higher quality employees.

We must be on the same wavelenght here. I just wrote a similar post but took a slightly different direction. I agree that a resume really says nothing about who you are or what you are really about.

I took the basic form of the resume and filled it with my Life. I made a Life Resume that speaks about who I am, what's important to me, and all the things I am truly proud of and happy about. My Life Resume is more true to who I am than any professional resume ever could be. It's not really designed to land a job, but who knows, maybe it would do a better job than a traditional resume.

I figure a life resume will get you much further in the long run than a professional resume. I think a life resume will give you the opportunity to showcase your values which are so important in career success.

Srini,

I think people are sick and tired of old wine in new bottle and want something new.

The era of standardization, mass production, uniformity is drawing to a close, because people are bored of being forced into a box.

When everybody is in the same box, the box becomes a prison. We want to be outside, to sing with the birds and swim with the fish in the endless blue surfs of the ocean, no?

That's where the individuality comes into play, which you can't really share on a one pager.
We want to express our unique gifts as individuals standing apart from the crowds.

It would be a boring world if everybody were just like everybody else. Hence, we want tailor-made and custom-designed stuff these days to float our boat and not WalMart Inc.

Cheers, dude.

Archan,

I think it's a great thing that an era of uniformity, fitting in, etc, etc are coming to a close since it never really worked for me. Outside the box is where I was meant to be. I think that one page resumes will never get anybody to their dream job or enable them to express individuality.

This is spot on, Srinirao. The other place where job ads and resumes really miss the mark is that they are all about medium. You're matching your skill-set and experience against what some employer thinks they need. But you're much more likely to find a good fit when you seek people out based on message and values. If you go via the typical job-board route you're just trying to fit yourself into the frame someone created—your trying to be best in an existing market. Better to create a market just for you.

Lach

You pretty much hit the nail on the head. The problem with the typical job search route is that it's not based on a person's values. As a byproduct we have tons of people in the world who absolutely hate their jobs.

haha - why do I hear the Jaws theme song playing in the background when I read this?

Maybe because YOU A SHARK.

And this shit is spot on.

Brilliant.

Wait, should I not have mentioned "shark" to a surfer? lol.

xo

Ash,

I don't know if I'm a shark, since they are generally in suits and the only suit I really wear on a regular basis is a wetsuit. Strangely, getting eaten by a shark seems to be low on my list of fears. But I really hope that college students and graduate students will take my advice to heart and see that there really is something here.

Branding is everything. I'm a full believer in that! Resumes don't get you anywhere!

Jenny,

No doubt. If you want people to know who you really are then branding is essential. A personal brand is a much more in-depth view into who you are.

Like Scott intimated, my resume got me noticed ahead of the pack for the one job I ever got interviewed for. It was then up to me to allow my personality to shine through on the day and get the job. The irony is, like you said Srini, it wasn't my dream job, not by a long shot. Within a year of starting I was pregnant with my first child and counting down the days until I could leave!

Actually, I never thanked my eldest daughter but having her is what set the cogs in motion to ensure I never need a resume ever again. I'll be sure to let her know how much I appreciate that when she wakes up. ;)

El,

It's kind of amazing how that works. I owe the boss who decided not to offer me a job after my summer internship a serious thank you. HE told me he'd be doing me a disservice by hiring me and while it really angered me at the time, he really did me a favor. As far as resumes go, I can't see how somebody would chose to be dependent on solely that if they expected to get a job they really loved.

Hi Srini,

I guess the reason recruiters rely on traditional methods like the resume is to standardize the first step into the selection process. If everyone has to produce the same kind of info. in a similar way then it's easier to filter those applicants through to the next stage i.e. interviews etc. (though interviews also have limitations in how well they identify the most suitable candidates).

I agree with you that recruiters will somehow have to pay more attention to how people are building personal brands as alternatives to the tradi8tional ways of hiring folk.

Scott,

In my mind what it comes down to is this. If you want a linchpin job then a resume is not going to cut it. If you want a cookie cutter job, then a resume will be the way to go. The process is definitely broken considering the amount of people who hate their jobs.

Great post Srini!

I always have felt writing resumes to be an exercise in meaningless jabber. How can an employer possibly learn who I am as a person and what I stand for with that dull script?

Now that I've transitioned to developing my personal brand, I still find it extremely difficult to break the "resume style" of writing that I've was so accustomed too.

Eric

P.S. How's the surfin'?

Eric,

Resumes are eventually going to die in my opinion. As you said, an employer really will never learn much about you from your resume. Sure it might get your foot in the door to a job that is not your dream job. But at the end of the day do we really want to live like that? Surf here has been kind of lousy for what seems like the last month. Hopefully with December that will change.